Products
Costco bakery in Canada: cake prices, the pumpkin pie, and what's worth buying
The Costco bakery's 12-inch pumpkin pie is $7.99 in Western Canada this fall, croissants are 12 for $5.99, and a plain sheet cake was last photographed at $24.99. Prices from Canadian warehouses with dates, what's the best value, and how to order a cake.
By Cost Check Editorial · Last reviewed Oct 3, 2026 · 3 min read
The Costco bakery in Canada is one of the cheapest places to feed a crowd: the 12-inch pumpkin pie was $7.99 in Western Canadian warehouses on October 2, 2026, about $4.32 a kilo, and 12 all-butter croissants were $5.99. Our advice: the pie, croissants and bagels are the standout buys; the specialty cakes cost three to four times more per kilo, so buy them for an occasion, not as everyday value.
How much do Costco bakery items cost in Canada?
These are the latest Canadian prices we could source, each photographed in a warehouse by the Costco West and Costco East fan blogs. Prices vary by province and change over time, so treat them as a guide and check the shelf.
| Item | Size | Price | Where and when |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12" pumpkin pie | 1.85 kg | $7.99 | B.C., Alberta, Sask. and Manitoba, October 2, 2026 |
| 12" lattice apple pie | 2.1 kg | $14.99 | Same, October 2, 2026 |
| All-butter croissants | 12 (825 g) | $5.99 | Port Coquitlam, B.C., May 2026 |
| Muffins (4 flavours) | Pack | $7.99 | Same |
| Plain bagels | 8 (1 kg) | $4.99 | Same |
| Tuxedo cake | 1.24 kg | $19.99 | Same |
| Strawberry cheesecake | 1.9 kg | $26.99 | Same |
| Plain cheesecake | Whole | $23.99 | Same |
| White or chocolate sheet cake | 4.31 kg | $24.99 | Port Coquitlam, B.C., January 2024 |
Seen a different price at your Costco? Upload your receipt: we read every line, add the prices to the site, and you earn points.
How much is the Costco pumpkin pie in Canada?
$7.99 in Western Canada this fall: the same 12-inch, 1.85 kg pie (item 11226) was $7.99 on October 10, 2025 and again on October 2, 2026. In Ontario and Atlantic Canada it was $6.99 in October 2024, the most recent eastern price we could source. It's a seasonal item, on shelves for Thanksgiving in both of the last two years, and it's a custard pie, so keep it in the fridge.
Which Costco bakery items are the best value?
Price per unit tells the story. Using the prices above:
| Item | Price per unit | Our take |
|---|---|---|
| Pumpkin pie | About $4.32 per kg | The best value in the bakery |
| Sheet cake (2024 price) | About $5.80 per kg | Unbeatable for a party, if you can eat 4 kg of cake |
| All-butter croissants | About 50 cents each | A staple; they freeze well |
| Bagels | About 62 cents each | Good value, and they freeze |
| Strawberry cheesecake | About $14.21 per kg | Fine for an occasion, not a bargain |
| Tuxedo cake | About $16.12 per kg | You pay for the layers and finish |
Have Costco bakery prices gone up?
Yes, for some items. Comparing the same item numbers in the same B.C. warehouse, the Tuxedo cake went from $18.99 in January 2024 to $19.99 in May 2026, and the strawberry-topped cheesecake from $23.99 to $26.99. The pumpkin pie held at $7.99 in Western Canada between October 2025 and October 2026. Tracking prices like this, item by item, is what Cost Check does: see Costco prices we track.
How do you order a cake from the Costco bakery?
In person. At the bakery, fill in the paper cake order form (flavour, design and the message), choose a pickup time, and drop it in the order box. Canadian shoppers report that warehouses need at least 24 hours' notice; around holidays, order earlier. We found no online cake ordering on Costco.ca, and options can differ by warehouse, so ask your bakery what it offers.
When is the Costco bakery open?
The bakery keeps the warehouse's hours, and Costco is closed on some statutory holidays, including Thanksgiving Monday, October 12, 2026. Check your warehouse's hours, and the full holiday list, in our Costco hours guide before you plan a pickup.
Frequently asked questions
- How much is a Costco pumpkin pie in Canada?
- $7.99 in Western Canadian warehouses on October 2, 2026, for the 12-inch, 1.85 kg pie. It was $6.99 in Ontario and Atlantic Canada in October 2024.
- How much is a Costco sheet cake in Canada?
- The last Canadian price we could source was $24.99 for the 4.31 kg white or chocolate sheet cake, in a B.C. warehouse in January 2024. Check your warehouse, as prices have risen on other cakes since.
- Can you order a Costco cake online in Canada?
- No online ordering that we could find. Fill in the paper form at the bakery, at least 24 hours ahead.
- How much are Costco croissants in Canada?
- 12 all-butter croissants were $5.99 in a B.C. warehouse in May 2026, about 50 cents each.
- Is the Costco bakery open on Thanksgiving?
- No. Costco warehouses are closed on Thanksgiving Monday, October 12, 2026; see our hours guide for other holidays.
Products